Introduction
Tucked away on a quiet corner of Bleecker Street, Five Odd Fellows promises a dining experience unlike any other in Greenwich Village. But does it deliver on that promise of being truly unique? The name alone sparks curiosity, conjuring images of secret societies and perhaps, equally mysterious culinary concoctions. Five Odd Fellows offers a surprisingly delightful experience, blending innovative dishes with a quirky atmosphere, though it’s not without its eccentricities. This review will delve into the specifics of this establishment, examining its ambiance, cuisine, service, and overall value, to determine whether it’s worth a visit. For food lovers looking for a fresh take on dining in New York City, Five Odd Fellows food & drink is a must-try.
Ambiance and Atmosphere: A Step into Another World
Stepping inside Five Odd Fellows is akin to stepping into a carefully curated Victorian parlor, albeit one with a decidedly modern twist. The decor is a delightful mix of vintage and contemporary, featuring plush velvet seating, exposed brick walls adorned with eclectic artwork, and antique chandeliers casting a warm, inviting glow. Mismatched chairs add to the quirky charm, creating a sense of playful informality. The color palette leans towards rich jewel tones – deep blues, emerald greens, and ruby reds – contributing to an atmosphere that’s both opulent and cozy.
The walls are lined with bookshelves filled with antique tomes and oddities, reinforcing the “Odd Fellows” theme. You might find a vintage globe next to a taxidermied raven, or a collection of antique clocks that seem to have stopped at different times, creating a sense of suspended animation. The music, typically a blend of classic jazz and soulful blues, further enhances the mood, creating a sophisticated yet relaxed ambiance.
The noise level is generally moderate, making it easy to carry on a conversation without having to shout. The crowd tends to be a mix of locals, tourists, and art students, drawn to the restaurant’s unique character and reputation for creative cuisine. Five Odd Fellows straddles the line between being a spot for a romantic dinner and a casual outing with friends, though the slightly higher price point might make it more suitable for special occasions or when one is looking to splurge. The overall energy is vibrant and engaging, making it a welcome change from the often sterile and predictable dining experiences found elsewhere in the city. The unique atmosphere makes Five Odd Fellows food & drink memorable.
The Food: Standout Dishes That Dare to Be Different
The menu at Five Odd Fellows is as intriguing as its name, featuring a selection of dishes that are both familiar and unconventional. The chef clearly isn’t afraid to experiment with flavors and textures, resulting in a culinary experience that’s both surprising and satisfying.
One standout dish is the Pan-Seared Duck Breast with Fig and Balsamic Glaze. The duck is cooked to perfection, boasting a crispy skin and a tender, juicy interior. The fig and balsamic glaze adds a touch of sweetness and acidity, creating a beautiful balance of flavors. The dish is served atop a bed of creamy polenta and garnished with toasted walnuts, providing a delightful textural contrast. This dish is a testament to the chef’s ability to elevate classic dishes with innovative twists.
Another must-try is the Lobster Ravioli with Saffron Cream Sauce. The ravioli is handmade in-house and filled with succulent lobster meat. The saffron cream sauce is rich and decadent, adding a touch of luxury to the dish. The ravioli is garnished with freshly grated Parmesan cheese and a sprinkle of red pepper flakes, providing a subtle kick of heat. This dish is a seafood lover’s dream, showcasing the freshest ingredients and impeccable culinary technique.
For vegetarians, the Roasted Beet Salad with Goat Cheese and Candied Pecans is a delightful option. The beets are roasted to perfection, bringing out their natural sweetness. The creamy goat cheese provides a tangy counterpoint, while the candied pecans add a touch of sweetness and crunch. The salad is dressed with a light vinaigrette, allowing the flavors of the ingredients to shine through. The presentation of each dish is also carefully considered, adding to the overall dining experience. Each plate is a work of art, showcasing the chef’s attention to detail and commitment to quality. The innovative food alone makes Five Odd Fellows food & drink worth visiting.
The Drinks: Creative Cocktails and Notable Selections
The drink menu at Five Odd Fellows is equally impressive, featuring a wide selection of beers, wines, and cocktails. The focus is on quality and craftsmanship, with many of the ingredients being sourced locally or made in-house. The cocktail list is particularly noteworthy, featuring a range of creative concoctions that are both delicious and visually appealing.
The signature cocktail is the “Odd Fellows Elixir,” a concoction of gin, elderflower liqueur, lime juice, and cucumber. The drink is refreshing and aromatic, with a perfect balance of sweet, sour, and bitter flavors. It’s garnished with a cucumber ribbon and a sprig of mint, making it a visually stunning drink as well. This elixir perfectly embodies the spirit of the restaurant, being both classic and unconventional.
Another popular cocktail is the “Smoked Old Fashioned,” a twist on the classic whiskey cocktail. The whiskey is smoked with cherry wood chips, giving it a unique smoky flavor. The drink is then mixed with sugar, bitters, and a splash of water, and garnished with an orange peel. This cocktail is perfect for whiskey lovers looking for something a little different. The cocktail selection is an important part of the Five Odd Fellows food & drink experience.
For beer lovers, there’s a rotating selection of craft beers on tap, featuring both local and international brews. The wine list is also carefully curated, featuring a range of wines from around the world, with a focus on smaller, independent producers. Non-alcoholic options include handcrafted sodas and juices, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
Service and Value: A Balancing Act
The service at Five Odd Fellows is generally attentive and friendly, though it can be a bit inconsistent at times. On some occasions, the staff is incredibly knowledgeable and eager to please, going above and beyond to ensure that guests have a memorable experience. On other occasions, the service can be a bit slow and impersonal, leaving guests feeling neglected. However, the staff is always polite and professional, even when they’re busy.
The price point at Five Odd Fellows is on the higher side, with entrees averaging around $30 and cocktails around $15. While the quality of the food and drinks is generally excellent, the prices may be a bit steep for some budgets. However, the unique atmosphere and overall dining experience help to justify the cost. For those looking for a special occasion restaurant or willing to splurge on a memorable meal, Five Odd Fellows is definitely worth considering.
Whether the experience is worth the cost depends on individual preferences and priorities. If you’re looking for a quick, inexpensive meal, Five Odd Fellows is probably not the best choice. However, if you’re looking for a unique dining experience that’s both creative and memorable, Five Odd Fellows is definitely worth the investment. The unique combination of Five Odd Fellows food & drink makes the pricing reasonable.
Conclusion: An Oddly Delightful Experience
Five Odd Fellows offers a genuinely unique dining experience that’s both surprising and satisfying. The innovative dishes, creative cocktails, quirky atmosphere, and attentive service combine to create a memorable meal that’s unlike anything else in Greenwich Village. While the price point may be a bit high for some, the overall experience is well worth the cost for those looking for something special.
Five Odd Fellows is recommended for adventurous eaters, those looking for a romantic dinner, or anyone who appreciates a unique and creative dining experience. It’s not a place for those seeking a quick or inexpensive meal, but rather a destination for those who want to savor the moment and indulge in culinary artistry. In short, if you’re looking for a restaurant that dares to be different, Five Odd Fellows is definitely worth a visit. It’s a place where the oddities come together to create something truly special, confirming that the combination of Five Odd Fellows food & drink is a winning one. I’d highly recommend it and would return to further explore the menu. This dining experience earns a solid four out of five stars.
